Disagree with reviewer comments. Sep 20, 2021 · Even if you ultimately disagree with a reviewer comment, respectfully acknowledging their input and explaining your thought processes goes a long way towards making that reviewer an ally for your paper. If there are any revisions you truly cannot make, note those in the response letter too. [List the other comments for this section in the same format. Example 1: Disagree with reviewer comment Reviewer comment Comments on introduction: a brief outline of how the water is supplied to the area would be How to respond to reviewers’ comments . Sometimes peer reviewers write long-winded comments, which make it difficult to pinpoint the specific aspects you need to address. The most important thing is to remain polite and constructive in your responses, even if a peer reviewer has been outright rude (it happens) or is simply incorrect in their assertions or conclusions about your work (it happens). Similar to the submission package for manuscript, when resubmitting a manuscript the resubmission package includes a response letter to the reviewers, which generally begins by thanking the reviewers for their commentary and includes a brief description of the major changes to the revised manuscript incurred by the feedback received; it Apr 3, 2019 · Here are four simple tips to help you respond to reviewers’ comments and fast track your paper for a positive decision! C: Comprehend (keep your cool!) When the decision letter arrives, read over the comments…Take time to understand the reviewers’ feedback and consider what they are asking you to do. ] Jun 21, 2022 · The goal of every author is to have their research work published. ] Response: [Follow the patterns recommended above. Try not to react emotionally or defensively, even if you disagree with some of the feedback. If the reviewers had similar comments, do not ask one reviewer to “see response to Reviewer 2,” or simply write “Comment 1: See response to comment 4 from Reviewer 1. Maintain a professional and respectful tone, and consider the comment as an opportunity to improve your work. First, emphasize any part of the reviewer’s comment you agree with. ] Response: Type your response here, unitalicized. It may come as a surprise, but you can disagree with reviewers. Although some of these comments are straightforward and concise, others are conflicting and unclear and, as such, authors may find it challenging to plan and carry out Jan 26, 2023 · What should I do if a reviewer makes a comment that I disagree with? It’s important to address the reviewer’s comment and provide evidence or reasoning for why you disagree. Instead, state that the reviewer has raised a good point and try to argue in a more positive tone why you do not agree, providing as many facts as possible to support your argument. In the process of publishing a peer-reviewed article, authors are often required to revise their original manuscript based on the comments from the reviewers. This is to ensure the quality, originality and accuracy of the work submitted to the journals. Apr 13, 2022 · Use formal language in all responses to the reviewers’ comments. Then explain why you chose not to make the change. Jun 19, 2024 · When responding to reviewer comments, always maintain a professional and respectful tone. Sometimes it is not attainable or sensible to incorporate all reviewer comments in the revisions of your manuscript. Always keep in mind that the peer review process is a dialogue, and it is quite natural to respectfully disagree with the reviewer (and the editor) as long as you make a good argument why. Remember that each reviewer has probably spent several hours going over your submission. "The editors and reviewers don't have time to check the new draft line by line and find the author's changes. Also pay careful attention to the reviewer's comments and if possible Apr 5, 2021 · Then repeat this for all comments by all reviewers! What To Actually Include In Your Reply To Reviewers. Provide Supporting Information Setting the Right Tone Part 1 Positive Phrases That Can Be Used in a Performance Review Part 2 How to Highlight an Employee’s Strengths with Specific Examples Part 3 Example Comments to Include to Provide Constructive Feedback Part 4 Structuring Your Comments Part 5 Using Examples in Comments Part 6 Encouraging Continuous Development Part 7 You can always disagree with a reviewer (to a certain extent, of course, if you want your manuscript to be published). Responding to reviewer critiques can be one of the most difficult steps in the publication process. Reviewers are experts in your field, and their feedback is intended to strengthen your work. Let's see examples of polite and respectful responses. 2 This is an important step as Mar 6, 2020 · The type of reviewer comments can be quite drastic from simple grammatical errors that need to be addressed to more comprehensive comments regarding redesigning experiments and compiling new data. Apr 3, 2023 · Even if you disagree with the reviewer's comments, try to avoid getting defensive or aggressive. Comments from Reviewer 1 Comment 1: [Paste the first comment here and italicize it. May 2, 2024 · The first step is to read the decision letter and the reviewers' comments carefully and calmly. Either way, you need to go through every single one of the comments and explain what Jul 10, 2021 · If you choose to disagree with a reviewer’s comment, provide evidence in support of your point. Choose your words carefully when drafting your response to revision requests. Avoid defensive or confrontational language, and express gratitude for the reviewers' time and effort. It’s also highly likely that Feb 12, 2015 · "The main mistake I see in authors' responses to reviewers' comments is in what I call the 'ergonomy' of the information – how well it's described to the editors and reviewers," says Professor Pázsit. When you write your response to reviewer comments, you then have the option to make the changes that the reviewers recommend or not. In these situations, you have to politely but firmly disagree with reviewers. If you do not agree with the reviewer you have to explain and defend your reasoning. Disagreements or rebuttals: If you disagree with a reviewer’s comment, provide a well-reasoned and evidence-based response. This can take the form of a single sentence after you have answered any questions and thanked the reviewer, such as: “We have added a discussion of this topic to the manuscript (lines 85–88). Be respectful and open to dialogue, but also defend your research and methodology if necessary. In some cases, you may believe that the reviewer is vengeful or is a competitor who has an ulterior motive to delay the manuscript. In other words, it is important to explain yourself when responding to the editors. Feb 3, 2023 · The power of this method is that it allows you to swap around the order of the reviewer's comments, or to group comments together, or even to group together a comment from reviewer 1 with a comment from review 2. ” Each comment from each reviewer deserves an individual response, even if you use the same text in your separate responses to the 2 reviewers. Reviewers' Comments to the Authors: Reviewer 1 When you disagree with a reviewer’s comment. " Tips for revisions and responding to review comments. Finally, remember to thank the reviewers (and the Editor, if Apr 1, 2011 · Restate the reviewer's comment. All page numbers refer to the revised manuscript file with tracked changes. For this type of feedback, it is important to remember that it is okay to disagree with the reviewer’s comments if they pertain to authorship. ] Comments from Reviewer 2 Comment 1: [Paste the full comment here and italicize it. And there is a proper way to do it. ” Take their concerns seriously. Once you receive reviewer comments for your submission, go through them very carefully a couple of times. Here are some examples of answers if you disagree with the reviewer: Oct 17, 2013 · Addressing peer reviewers' comments is a daunting task for even the most experienced authors. Below is an example of feedback that may be given along with this status and how a contributor might respond. Even if you disagree with a comment, respond in a courteous Mar 11, 2019 · Writing Your Response to Reviewer Comments. Even if you disagree with the reviewer’s comment, they still have to approve your manuscript for publication. Those changes are highlighted within the manuscript. Avoid taking a strong or argumentative tone if you happen to disagree on any issues. Generally, reading through the reviewer comments for the first time can be quite overwhelming as one attempts to identify what the reviewers are Perform any additional experiments or analyses the reviewers recommend (unless you feel that they would not make your paper better; if this is the case, explain why in your response letter) Provide a polite and scientific rebuttal to any points or comments you disagree with; Differentiate between reviewer comments and your responses in your letter May 18, 2021 · Researchers have voiced frustrations that reviewer comments can be contradictory and patronising, and even biased or unprofessional in tone. You can show evidence from your own work or citations from previous literature that show the validity of your statement. Your strategy can be a game changer here: a thoughtful, clear and effective response to the reviewers can not only speed up the publication process but it also gives you a chance to improve your work, to show professionalism, and eventually to gain Oct 12, 2017 · When specific comments seem off-base, and especially when a single reviewer has many such comments, this may be because the manuscript does not sufficiently explain the hypothesis it aims to address. For every single point raised by the reviewers, you should do the following: Address their concern: Do you agree or disagree with the reviewer’s comment? Either way, make your position clear and justify any differences of opinion. It is highly flexible. Contents Critical reflection before We have incorporated most of the suggestions made by the reviewers. Sep 20, 2019 · If you get peer review comments back on your work that you disagree with, stay calm. Respond to each comment – even if you disagree. Example 1: . Peer review is the indispensable part of publishing a scientific paper, in particulars in high-impact journals. Don’t just say that you disagree and not defend your argument. The only rule is that you must include all text of the reviews. Please see below, in blue, for a point-by-point response to the reviewers’ comments and concerns. May 7, 2019 · Frequently encountered deficiencies among authors’ responses to reviewers’ or editors’ comments include ignoring or incompletely addressing these comments, not being specific about where and what exactly was changed within the manuscript, not knowing how to address differing or contradicting suggestions of the reviewers, providing inadequate evidence as justification for not making Disagree with reviewer comments If you disagree with a comment then you need to justify why in your response to the comment in the separate response file. 1 The next immediate step after peer review, if the authors are lucky enough, is to revise the manuscript according to editors’ and reviewers’ comments.
acs dol rsolxgs iexxt glzxm zgs xtdgz emnukt xdjab kjpjmsq